0 Items - $0.00 My account / Register
 The Initial Choice is a full-service monogram and gift shop, located in Lake Forest, IL. We offer a wide variety of gifts for loved ones or for yourself! Make it extra special by adding a custom monogram.
  • Home
  • Babies & Toddlers
    • Accessories
      • Jewelry
    • Animal Blankies
    • Apparel
    • Baby Mat
    • Bibs and Burps
    • Blankets & Lovies
    • Caps and Hats
    • Frames
    • Hooded Towels
    • Keepsake
    • Outerwear
    • Pillows
    • Toys
      • Books
  • Children
    • Plush
    • Accessories
    • Apparel
    • Bags
    • Hooded Towels
    • Outerwear
    • Robes
    • Sweaters
    • Tabletop
    • Toys
      • Banks
      • Books
      • Plush
  • For Her
    • Accessories
      • Cosmetics
      • Scarves, Gloves and Hats
      • Wallets and Cases
    • Bath & Body
    • Apparel
    • Bags
    • Pajamas
    • Robes
  • For Him
    • Accessories
      • Bracelets
      • Can Coolers
      • Cuff Links
      • Flasks
      • Key Fobs
      • Sunglass Straps
    • Belts
    • Hats
    • Outerwear
    • Robes
    • Travel
    • Wallets and Card Wallets
  • For Home
    • Accessories
    • Candles/Fragrance
    • Collegiate
    • Drinkware
    • Frames
    • Keepsake
    • Mariposa
    • Paper Products
      • Cards
      • Stationery
    • Pets
    • Pillows
    • Rugs
    • Tabletop
    • Throws
    • Towels
  • Local
    • Lake Bluff
    • Lake Forest
    • Chicago
    • Other
  • EG Stationery

Keepsake

Home / Babies & Toddlers / Keepsake
Min: $0
Max: $150
  • Babies & Toddlers
    • Accessories
    • Animal Blankies
    • Apparel
    • Baby Mat
    • Bibs and Burps
    • Blankets & Lovies
    • Caps and Hats
    • Frames
    • Hooded Towels
    • Keepsake
    • Outerwear
    • Pillows
    • Toys
  • Children
  • For Her
  • For Him
  • For Home
  • Local
Salisbuy Pewter Easton Pewter Cup w/cross
Commemorate the special day, with the particularly lovely handcrafted Easton baby cup with cross.
Add to cart
Salisbuy Pewter Easton Pewter Cup w/cross
$95.00
Beatriz Ball Athens Cross Ornament- Periwinkle
Beatriz Ball Athens Cross Ornament- Periwinkle
Add to cart
Beatriz Ball Athens Cross Ornament- Periwinkle
$27.00
Cherished Moments TCN Cross Diamond Necklace
From our "Timeless Collection" this cross pendant necklace is a beautiful keepsake piece featuring a tiny sparkling diamond that's just perfect for a First Communion or Baptism gift.  
Add to cart
Cherished Moments TCN Cross Diamond Necklace
$68.00
Cherished Moments Destiny Sterling & Pearl Heart Bracelet 0-12m
Precious sterling silver bracelet crafted with genuine high-end Austrian simulated pearls accented with a silver drop heart in the center - a treasured keepsake!
Add to cart
Cherished Moments Destiny Sterling & Pearl Heart Bracelet 0-12m
$30.00
Cherished Moments Addie Christening Bracelet 6-12yr xx
Customer favorite! Sterling silver bracelet with beautiful pink and white high-end Austrian simulated pearls accented with sparkling silver daisies.
Add to cart
Cherished Moments Addie Christening Bracelet 6-12yr xx
$30.00
Cherished Moments Cross Necklace w/CZ Sterling 14"
Gorgeous sparkling sterling silver cross charm necklace with CZs on a 14" chain with a high-quality lobster clasp.
Add to cart
Cherished Moments Cross Necklace w/CZ Sterling 14"
$40.00
Cherished Moments Serenity Sterling Silver First Pearl Bracelet 6-12yr
Her first Pearls! Simply beautiful sterling silver bracelet featuring a strand of gorgeous high-end simulated Austrian pearls (4mm). 
Add to cart
Cherished Moments Serenity Sterling Silver First Pearl Bracelet 6-12yr
$28.00
Cherished Moments Olivia Silver Cross Bracelet Small 0-12m
Beautiful keepsake sterling silver bracelet with genuine high-end Austrian simulated pearls and an intricate silver cross - perfect for baptisms, christenings and communion!  
Add to cart
Cherished Moments Olivia Silver Cross Bracelet Small 0-12m
$36.00
Coton Colors 6" Pinstripe Cross Pink
This ceramic cross features a beautiful hand-drawn background of pastel pink stripes, a bolder pink border, and a hole for easy hanging.
Add to cart
Coton Colors 6" Pinstripe Cross Pink
$17.00
Salisbuy Pewter Keepsake Box Plain
Salisbuy Pewter Keepsake Box Plain
Add to cart
Salisbuy Pewter Keepsake Box Plain
$80.00
Salisbuy Pewter Pewter Baby Cup w/ Bow Handle
This beautiful U.S.A. handcrafted pewter baby cup is a darling gift that will charm and delight for years to come.
Add to cart
Salisbuy Pewter Pewter Baby Cup w/ Bow Handle
$84.00
Salisbuy Pewter Teddy Keepsake Box
This adorable handmade pewter keepsake box with its gold teddy bear on top is the perfect gift to hold all the tiny things.
Add to cart
Salisbuy Pewter Teddy Keepsake Box
$92.00
Page 2 of 4
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4


  • About Us
  • Embroidery Services
  • Shipping & Returns
  • Locations
  • Job Opportunities
  • All products
  • New products
  • Offers
  • Tags
  • RSS feed
  • Register
  • My orders
  • My tickets
  • My wishlist
Lake Forest's original monogram store!
847-234-5884
[email protected]

© Copyright 2026 The Initial Choice - Powered by Lightspeed
Credit Card