0 Items - $0.00 My account / Register
 The Initial Choice is a full-service monogram and gift shop, located in Lake Forest, IL. We offer a wide variety of gifts for loved ones or for yourself! Make it extra special by adding a custom monogram.
  • Home
  • Babies & Toddlers
    • Accessories
      • Jewelry
    • Apparel
    • Baby Mat
    • Bibs and Burps
    • Blankets & Lovies
    • Caps and Hats
    • Frames
    • Hooded Towels
    • Keepsake
    • Outerwear
    • Pillows
    • Toys
      • Books
      • Plush
  • Children
    • Accessories
    • Apparel
    • Bags
    • Hooded Towels
    • Outerwear
    • Robes
    • Sweaters
    • Tabletop
    • Toys
      • Banks
      • Books
      • Plush
  • For Her
    • Accessories
      • Cosmetics
      • Scarves, Gloves and Hats
      • Wallets and Cases
    • Bath & Body
    • Apparel
    • Bags
    • Outerwear
    • Pajamas
    • Robes
  • For Him
    • Accessories
      • Bracelets
      • Can Coolers
      • Cuff Links
      • Flasks
      • Key Fobs
      • Sunglass Straps
    • Belts
    • Hats
    • Outerwear
    • Robes
    • Travel
    • Wallets and Card Wallets
  • For Home
    • Accessories
    • Candles/Fragrance
    • Drinkware
    • Frames
    • Keepsake
    • Mariposa
    • Paper Products
      • Cards
      • Stationery
    • Pets
    • Pillows
    • Rugs
    • Tabletop
    • Throws
    • Towels
  • Local
    • Lake Bluff
    • Lake Forest
    • Chicago
    • Other
  • Holidays
    • Accessories
    • Carolers
    • Ornaments
    • Pillows
    • Plush
    • Rugs
    • Stockings
    • Tabletop
  • EG Stationery

Toys

Home / Babies & Toddlers / Toys
Min: $0
Max: $150
  • Babies & Toddlers
    • Accessories
    • Apparel
    • Baby Mat
    • Bibs and Burps
    • Blankets & Lovies
    • Caps and Hats
    • Frames
    • Hooded Towels
    • Keepsake
    • Outerwear
    • Pillows
    • Toys
      • Books
      • Plush
  • Children
  • For Her
  • For Him
  • For Home
  • Local
  • Holidays
Mary Meyer Toys Again Friends Elephant
Introducing Again Friends, Mary Meyer’s new line of recycled plush toys that are not only cute and cuddly but also SUSTAINABLE.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Again Friends Elephant
$26.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Molasses Sloth
6×6″ Taggies was born over a decade ago when a mom noticed her child’s fascination with satin tags. This idea blossomed into a world of treasured products.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Molasses Sloth
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Fox
Part soother, part activity toy.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Fox
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Again Friends Frog
Introducing Again Friends, Mary Meyer’s new line of recycled plush toys that are not only cute and cuddly but also SUSTAINABLE.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Again Friends Frog
$26.00
Jelly Cat Bartholomew Bear Ring Rattle
A timeless character for curious newborns, easy to grab by any one of his four paws or round tummy and gently jangle.
Add to cart
Jelly Cat Bartholomew Bear Ring Rattle
$18.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Tilly Giraffe Soft Toy
You will be head over hoof with this theme. Sprinkled with spots and colors of sherbet, making her irresistibly sweet. Soft with delicate embroidery and famous Taggies ribbons.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Tilly Giraffe Soft Toy
$29.50
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Flora Fawn Soft Book
Taggies books are winning awards for their combination of stimulation (squeaker and crinkle paper inside) and soothing features (eight Taggies ribbons and textured fabric covers).
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Flora Fawn Soft Book
$24.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Sniggles Snake
Sniggles is our adorable plush snake made of super soft fabric with embroidered details.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Sniggles Snake
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Tippy Turtle
Tippy Turtle is an adorable plush toy with a pink textured shell fabric.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Tippy Turtle
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Rooster
Taggies crinkle squares are winning awards for their combination of stimulation (squeaker and crinkle paper inside) and soothing features (eight Taggies ribbons and textured fabric appliques).
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Rooster
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Flora Fawn
Taggies crinkle squares are winning awards for their combination of stimulation (squeaker and crinkle paper inside) and soothing features (eight Taggies ribbons and textured fabric appliques).
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Flora Fawn
$14.00
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Sleepy Seas
Ocean animals, especially in this lush aquamarine color, are hot right now. Taggies fans have always loved a punch of color. These toys are sure to swim into people’s hearts.
Add to cart
Mary Meyer Toys Taggies Crinkle Me Sleepy Seas
$14.00
Page 4 of 8
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 8


  • About Us
  • Embroidery Services
  • Shipping & Returns
  • Locations
  • Job Opportunities
  • All products
  • New products
  • Offers
  • Tags
  • RSS feed
  • Register
  • My orders
  • My tickets
  • My wishlist
Lake Forest's original monogram store!
847-234-5884
[email protected]

© Copyright 2025 The Initial Choice - Powered by Lightspeed
Credit Card